OnlyCaptions Logo

More results...

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Filter by Categories
Pick Up Lines
Quotes and Sayings

297 Scary Pick Up Lines to Make 'em Scream!

AI Pick Up Lines Generator

During the dark, eerie hours of the night, humans have a tendency to weave tales of horror and fear. We've all heard about haunted houses, vampires, witches, and ghouls in horror movies and stories. But what about the realm of romance? Amidst the purity of love, can we find something unsettling yet intriguing?

Imagine you're weaving through a sea of people under dimmed lights in a crowded bar, your eyes meet someone else's from across the room, and then all of a sudden, you’re stammering, palms sweating, trying to think of the perfect words to catch their attention. For the charmingly audacious and the frightfully bold, why not add a touch of chilling excitement being conveyed via some 'scary' pick-up lines? Such strange, eerie tactics might seem unconventional, but they may shockingly instigate a unique, intriguing conversation.

This article is not for the faint of heart—it's for those daring souls who are in search of something different and spine-chilling. We're here to take a deep, dark plunge into the world of innovative communication - 'scary' pick-up lines; a strangely fascinating intersection of flirtation and fear. If you're intrigued by the tantalizing thrill of the unconventional, read on.

Scary Pick Up Lines (2023)

Funny Scary Pick Up Lines (2023)

Where better to start than with those lines that blend the ominous with whimsy? Funny scary pick up lines are the perfect middle ground between a laugh-out-loud moment and a goosebumps-inducing chill running down your spine. Here, we present to you mildly haunting yet hilariously clever lines to lighten the eerie atmosphere and bring a smile (or a look of bemused horror) to your potential partner's face.

  • "Are you a witch? Because whenever I look at you, everyone else disappears."
  • "Is your name Freddy? Because I've been having nightmares about you."
  • "Do you have a Band-Aid? Because I just scraped my knee falling for you…in my haunted dream."
  • "If I said you had a ghoul body, would you hold it against me?"
  • "Did it hurt when you crawled out of the grave? Or are you always this enchantingly beautiful?"
  • "You must be a spellcaster because whenever I see you, you enchant me.”
  • "Are you a ghost? Because my heart is phantom-beating for you."
  • "Is it Halloween? Or am I witch-ing over you in panache?"
  • "Are you a full moon? Because you make the beast in me come alive."
  • "Are you a zombie? Because my heart feels dead when you're not around."
  • "Are we at a haunted house? Because my heart is screaming for you."
  • "My love for you is like a vampire—it's eternal."
  • "Your beauty sends shivers down my spine."
  • "Did we just share a page in the Necronomicon? Because I think we have a dead-ly connection."
  • "Are you made of ectoplasm? Because my heart is being pulled to you."
  • "Is your aura made of magic? Because I can hardly BREATH."
  • "Did we meet in purgatory? Because being away from you feels like hell."
  • "Do you believe in fate? Because I've been grave-digging you all night."
  • "Are you the headless horseman? Because I can't seem to get you out of my mind."
  • "You're the only treat I want in my trick or treat bag."
  • "Are you a vampire? Because my heart beats only for you."
  • "You've bewitched me, body and soul."
  • "Can I follow you home? Because my parents always told me to follow my nightmares."
  • "Is it just me, or did it just get dark around here when you stole my heart?"
  • "Are you a black cat? Because I'm spellbound by your beauty."
  • "You must be a werewolf because you make my heart howl."
  • "Are we zombies? Because we'd make a killer couple."
  • "Are you a goblin? Because my heart is goblin up its feelings for you."
  • "Are you a scarecrow? Because you have my heart cawing for attention."
  • "Is your name Dracula? Because I just cannot resist your bite."
  • "Are you a witch? Because you've bewitched my mind, body, and soul."
  • "Are you a vampire? Because my heart is staked on you."
  • "Did I meet you in a past life? Because you have haunted my dreams for ages."
  • "Is your name Frankenstein? Because you've electrified my heart."
  • "You must be a real ghost, because I just can't see myself without you."
  • "Your eyes are ghoulishly enchanting; I'm under your spell."
  • "Is your love a haunted house? Because I'm dying to get in."
  • "Are you a ghostbuster? Because I think you've just captured my heart."
  • "Are you my poltergeist? Because my heart is all aflutter."
  • "Tell me, does Heaven know they're missing an angel – or is Hell still searching for its devil?"
  • "Can I keep you? Just like the way a cemetery keeps its dead."
  • "It's funny, monsters are supposed to be scary, but I feel safe in your arms."
  • "Are you a mummy? Because whenever I look at you, I feel all wrapped up.”
  • "Are you a demon? Because your beauty is possession in the highest degree."
  • "I may not be an exorcist, but I can still rid you of your loneliness."

Cheesy Scary Pick Up Lines (2023)

While traditional pick-up lines have their charm, there's nothing quite like the powerful thrills provided by a scary and cheesy pick-up that's sure to strike a chord (or a nerve). This pleasantly perturbing blend of cheesiness and scare factor can have an uncanny appeal. To help get the adrenaline pumping, here's a collection of 'Cheesy Scary' pick-up lines that might just be useful in the odd, peculiar game of love:

  • "Is your name Phantasma? Because my heart is haunted by you."
  • "Baby, you must be a werewolf because you make my heart howl."
  • "Are you a ghost? Because you've been haunting my dreams all night."
  • "Do you believe in possession? Because I'm possessed by your love."
  • "Are you a witch? Because whenever I see you, it's like magic."
  • "My love for you is scarier than any horror movie."
  • "You're like a black cat, you've crossed my path and I'm mesmerized by you."
  • "Did I just step into an Alfred Hitchcock film? Because I'm psycho about you."
  • "You must be a spellcaster because every time I look into your eyes, I'm enchanted."
  • "Are you a poltergeist? Because I can feel your presence even when I can't see you."
  • "I must be a zombie, because I'm dying to have you."
  • "Is there a ghost nearby or is that just my heart beating rapidly for you?"
  • "Are you a vampire? Because my heart beats faster every time I see you."
  • "Is it Halloween or are you just bewitching me?"
  • "Did it hurt when you fell from heaven, or were you banished just for me?"
  • "Are we in a graveyard? Because my dead heart just came alive."
  • "If I was a vampire, I'd choose eternity just to be with you."
  • "You're like a full moon, invoking the beast within me."
  • "Are you a Coven's queen? Because you make me wanna join your witchcraft."
  • "You're so enchanting, it's almost scary."
  • "Is there a hex on me? Because I can't help but feel drawn to you."
  • "Are you a monster? Because you've created a rampage in my heart."
  • "You give me shivers, but not the scary kind.”
  • "Our love is like a ghost, something felt but not seen."
  • "Do you have a map? Because I'm lost in the catacombs of your love."
  • "You've cast a love spell on me, haven't you?"
  • "Are you made of ectoplasm? Because my heart's been summoned by you."
  • "Do you mind if I follow you home? My zombie instincts tell me to follow my tasty… I mean, loved ones."
  • "Your beauty can wake up the dead… figuratively of course!"
  • "Your love is like a haunted house – thrilling and exhilarating!"
  • "I must be in a horror movie, because your love is killing me."
  • "Baby, without you, I'm like a witch without her broom."
  • "You must be my lucky pentagram, because I can't seem to get away from you."
  • "Are you a werewolf? Because I'm lycan what I see."
  • "Is that a bat in your pocket, or does my vampire charm just excite you?"
  • "Have we met before in another haunted life?"
  • "Are you a sorcerer? Because there must be some magic behind the way I feel about you."
  • "You're the crypt to my ghoul, together until the end of life."
  • "Can I borrow your broomstick? Because my heart has flown away with you."
  • "I think I have sixth sense, because I see a future with you."
  • "Are we in a scary thriller? Because every moment without you is a sheer terror."
  • "Is it chilly in here, or did you just give me goosebumps?"

Scary Pick Up Lines For Tinder (2023)

Fear and romance converge on the thrilling realm of Tinder flirting. As we all delve more into the tradition of online dating, let's take a twisted turn and venture into the unexplored world of scary pick-up lines for Tinder. Below is a unique list of the 'creepy chic', a truly haunting collection for those looking to cast a spooky spell on their next Tinder match - don't say we didn't warn you!

  • “Is your name Freddy? Because you’ve haunted my dreams.”
  • “Are we in a graveyard, because my heart dies when I'm not with you."
  • “Does your heart beat for me? Because mine stopped when I saw your photo."
  • “You make my heart race so fast, it's like a zombie on the loose.”
  • “Are you a ghost? Because every time I look around, you're all I see.”
  • “Is your love an alien, because it's out of this world.”
  • “Baby, you must be a witch, because whenever I'm around you, everything else disappears.”
  • “Are you a haunted house? Because I'm terrified of how much I like you.”
  • “Our love is like a horror movie, it sends chills down my spine.”
  • “I must be a bat, because I'm completely drawn to your darkness.”
  • “Are you a monster? Because my heart is scared of how much it wants you.”
  • “Your love is like a full moon, it turns me into a werewolf.”
  • “You must be a spider, because I'm caught in your web.”
  • “Are you a specter? Because my heart is haunted by you.”
  • "Your eyes are so deep, it feels like falling into a dark abyss."
  • "Our love story could be a bestselling horror novel."
  • "Are you a demon? Because you've bewitched my soul."
  • "You must be a vampire, because my heart beats faster every time I see you."
  • "Are you a haunted doll? Because I can't take my eyes off of you."
  • "You must be a ghost, you seem to have possessed my mind."
  • "Are you a creature of the night? Because I can't resist your charm."
  • "Like a haunted house, I want to explore all your dark secrets."
  • "You must be a witch, because my heart levitates whenever you're near."
  • "Your look pierces through me, like a thrilling horror movie scene."
  • "Did you just put a spell on me? Because I can't think straight."
  • "Are you a supernatural entity? Because the attraction is otherworldly."
  • "Do you cast shadow magic? Because you've shrouded my heart in darkness."
  • "Is your aura a haunted forest? Because I want to lose myself in it."
  • "Like a phantom, you've taken over my thoughts completely."
  • "Your beauty is chilling like a ghostly apparition."
  • "Are you an enchantress? I'm bewitched by your charm."
  • "Even the darkest creatures of the night can't compete with your allure."
  • "Are you a werewolf? My heart howls for you."
  • "Just like a ghost town, you have an eerie fascination about you."
  • "Do you deal with necromancy? Because I feel alive again seeing you."
  • "You've charmed me like a siren with her song."
  • "Are you a horror director? Because I want to be your leading man/woman."
  • "Your allure is like a witch’s potion, intoxicating and impossible to resist."
  • "Our connection could light up a séance."
  • "Are you a medium? Because I can feel some supernatural chemistry between us."
  • "I'm obsessed with you the way a ghoul is obsessed with its graveyard."
  • "Are you an abyss? Because I'm falling for you helplessly."
  • "My love for you is eternal, like a vampire's life."
  • "I'm not afraid of the Boogeyman, but your beauty does scare me."
  • "Like a haunted mansion, your charm is wonderfully eerie."
  • "Do you know any magic? Because whenever I see you, everyone else disappears."
  • "Your love hits me harder than a jump scare in a horror movie."
  • "Can you feel it? Our destinies intertwining like a pair of twisted specters."

Cute Scary Pick Up Line (2023)

For the adventure-loving, horror-obsessed romantics among us, combining mystery and a playful touch of terror could surprisingly ignite a spark. We delve into the world of ‘Cute Scary Pick Up Lines’, a charmingly haunted realm perfect for sending chills down the spine while leaving a smile on the face.

  • "Your beauty makes my heart race like a haunted house. "
  • "Do you have a map? I just got lost in your eyes, just like in that twists and turns of a petrifying horror movie."
  • "Are you a ghost? Because you've been haunting my dreams all night."
  • "Excuse me, but I think you dropped something: my jaw, much like in the final scene of a really good horror film."
  • "Is your aura made of ectoplasm? Because my heart can't seem to escape your magnetic pull."
  • "Are you a vampire? Because my heart beats faster every time I see you."
  • "Your beauty is spellbinding, like a close encounter of the otherworldly kind."
  • "Just like a werewolf under a full moon, I am completely drawn to you."
  • "When I look into your eyes, I feel like I'm lost in a thrilling horror mystery."
  • "Are you a witch? Because whenever I’m around you, I feel bewitched."
  • "I must be a bat, because I'm completely drawn to your enchanting light."
  • "Your smile is more enchanting than a full moon on a quiet Halloween night."
  • "Were you fully apparating? Because I am spellbound by your charm."
  • "Every time I see you, my heart does the zombie walk."
  • "Were you forged in a haunted mansion? Because your beauty is supernatural."
  • "Do you come with coffee? You've just scared the sleep out of me."
  • "Are you a phantom? Because your beauty is otherworldly."
  • "Is there a spider on your face, or are you always this captivating?"
  • "Are you a black cat? Because you leave me spellbound with every step."
  • "Your loveliness haunts me, much like the ever-looming Grim Reaper."
  • "Your eyes are like the deepest abyss, I fear I may drown in them."
  • "Are we in a horror movie? Because my heart races whenever you're near."
  • "I must have been hexed, because I can't keep my eyes off you."
  • "Can I follow you home? Because like a lost spirit, I seem to have lost my way into your heart."
  • "Are you a mythological creature? Because your looks are too breathtaking to be real."
  • "Have you been casting spells? Because every time you smile, I feel charmed."
  • "My love for you is like a ghost, it's always there even when you can't see it."
  • "Are you an alien? Because there mustn’t be anybody like you on earth."
  • "Am I under your spell or are you always this enchanting?"
  • "Were you transformed by magic? Your charm surely isn't from this world."
  • "Are you a haunted doll? Because I am possessed by your charm."
  • "I must be under your bewitching terror, as every time I see you; you scare the solitude out of me."
  • "Are you a magician? Because whenever I'm around you, everyone else seems to vanish."
  • "I'm not afraid of ghosts, but I'm terrified of losing you."
  • "Are you an illusion? Each vision of you is more captivating than the last."
  • "Your charm is bewitching; even a hardened skeptic falls under your spell."
  • "Just like an old ghost tale, the allure of your charm is legendary."
  • "Are you a tormented spirit? Because my heart is haunted by your love."
  • "Have you cast a love spell on me? I can’t seem to resist your allure."
  • "Are you a nightmare? Because I am afraid to wake up from this beautiful dream."
  • "I must be a monster, because I can’t keep myself from devouring your love."
  • "You must be a sorcerer because you have entranced my heart."
  • "Are you a mirage? Even in the vast desert of life, I seem to find you."
  • "Did you cast a charm? My heart echoes with the spell of your laughter."
  • "Much like an unsolved mystery, you captivate my thoughts day and night."

Scary Pick Up Lines For Her (Girls)

When it comes to capturing a woman’s imagination, creating intrigue and desire, standard pick-up lines can sometimes fall flat. However, unexpected approaches can spark interest and conversation. For those adventurous women with a spine-chilling sense of humor, these scary pick-up lines are bound to draw attention and a memorable reaction. So let your creepy creativity run wild with these unique and scary pick-up lines for her.

  • "Are you a ghost? Because my heart is startled every time it spots you."
  • "Are you a vampire? I feel drawn to your irresistible bite."
  • "Is there a spell on me or do I just feel captivated every time I look at you?"
  • "Am I seeing a spirit or are you just angelically frightening?"
  • "I must be a bat, blindly attracted to your enigmatic charm."
  • "Are you a witch? Because your beauty has bewitched my heart."
  • "Here in my graveyard of past relationships, you unearth strange feelings in me."
  • "Is it Halloween or am I just bewitched by your charm?"
  • "I must be a zombie, for I crave you in the most ungodly manner."
  • "Are you a siren? Your voice sends tremors down my spine."
  • "Are you a full moon? Because I change to a beast in your presence."
  • "Being without you would be my greatest fear."
  • "The thought of you and me is a frighteningly beautiful dream."
  • "Your love is my sweet poison, so intoxicating, it's deadly."
  • "Am I possessed? I can't seem to get you out of my mind."
  • "Are you a phantom? Because you haunt my dreams."
  • "Like a creature of the night, I'm drawn to your mysterious allure."
  • "Are you a shadow? Because I can't seem to escape your captivating presence."
  • "You’re a sweet nightmare that I never want to wake up from."
  • "Your absence feels like a paranormal investigation—echoing silence."
  • "You enchant me more than the darkest forbidden spell ever could."
  • "Are you an alien? Because nothing on earth could be this enchantingly terrifying."
  • "Must be a full moon tonight, because I'm simply ravished by your sight."
  • "Are you a black cat? Cause bad luck isn't the only thing I'll risk for you."
  • "Like a chilling wind, your presence makes the hair on my neck rise in anticipation."
  • "Every love story is a ghost story, and I'm hauntingly drawn to you."
  • "Your beauty is like a magic potion, ceaselessly addictive and intoxicating."
  • "Being around you is like being on a ghost tour – spine-tingling and intriguing."
  • "Your allure is like a dark mystery itching to be solved."
  • "Your smile makes every horrifying thing suddenly seem beautiful."
  • "Are you my pumpkin queen? Because I'm simply spellbound by your charm."
  • "The thought of life without you terrifies me more than any ghost story."
  • "Is your name Medusa? Because I freeze whenever I look at you."
  • "Like a vampire, I find myself compelled to your ethereal beauty."
  • "In the darkest of nights, your eyes illuminate my path."
  • "Are you a sorcerer? Because my heart dances to your enchantments."
  • "In my universe of dark matter, you're the most terrifyingly beautiful anomaly."
  • "Your love is my kryptonite— an enthralling peril I'm willing to face."
  • "Just like the Bone Eater's Well, you inexplicably draw me in."
  • "Your charm, like a poltergeist, has unsettlingly upturned my world."
  • "You are my beautiful nemesis; I can't help but be captively drawn to."
  • "Are you a nightmare or a dream? Because my heart can’t decide."
  • "Your beauty is hauntingly mesmerizing, just like a mysterious moonlit night."
  • "Like Frankenstein, you've brought my feelings to life."
  • "Your love is a dark enchantment that I can't seem to resist."
  • "Even the darkest ghost stories cannot compete with the magic in your eyes."
  • "Your charm is the sweetest treat in this tricking life."
  • "In the middle of a tormented world, your love is my safe haunt."
  • "Is it a trick or treat? A love as frighteningly beautiful as yours is hard to defeat."

Scary Pick Up Lines For Him (Guys)

Charming or funny pick up lines can sound cliched sometimes. If you want to stand out and create a lasting impression in his mind, why not try something spooky yet fun? If your man appreciates a good horror movie, or if Halloween is just-around-the-corner, these scary pick up lines for him, sprinkled with a hint of humor and intrigue, will definitely spark an interesting conversation.

  • Are you a ghost? Because you've been haunting my dreams every night.
  • If I were a zombie, I’d eat you the last.
  • Is your name Freddy? Because you're invading my dreams.
  • Do you believe in the afterlife? Because, with that smile, I am seeing heaven.
  • Are you a vampire? Because my heart beats faster every time I see you.
  • I must be a witch because I am falling under your spell.
  • Your good looks must be cursed because they're killing me.
  • Can I take you to the underworld because my heart is hell-bent on you?
  • You strike me like lightning!
  • I would sell my soul to the devil for a date with you.
  • Are you Dracula? Because my heart beats uncontrollably around you.
  • Do you have a map? Because I just got lost in your haunted eyes.
  • Can I follow you home? Because my parents always told me to follow my nightmares.
  • Are you a scarecrow? Because you’ve just scared away all the rest.
  • Like a werewolf, I get wild under the full moon of your love.
  • Your love potion is definitely working.
  • You must be a spellcaster because whenever I look at you, everyone else disappears.
  • We'll make the perfect human centipede.
  • Are you my coffin? Because I'd willingly give up my breath for you.
  • You've cast a charm on me and I can't resist.
  • Are you a demon? Because you're possessively dominating my thoughts.
  • Were you bitten by a vampire? You're looking fang-tastic!
  • You give me goosebumps better than any horror movie.
  • I must be a haunted mansion because my heart thuds louder than a beating drum when you're near.
  • Are we in Stranger Things? Cause I feel a connection between us.
  • Are you a bat? 'Cause my heart is flying towards you.
  • Can we make a witches brew? We’ll need eye of newt, hair of bat, and a kiss from you.
  • Did you just cast Wingardium Leviosa? Because you've made my heart levitate.
  • You must be a magician because whenever I look at you, everyone else disappears.
  • Your beauty is so potent, it's like black magic.
  • Are you a Cthulhu cultist? You've driven me insane.
  • Are you a witch? You deserve to have my 'sand-witch'.
  • Are you a vampire? Because I cannot resist your bite.
  • Are you a zombie? Because you make me go weak in the knees.
  • Do you have a Band-Aid? I just hurt myself falling for the phantom that you are!
  • You must be the ghost of my future husband, because I’ve been looking for you my whole life.
  • Are you a skeleton? Because you're scare-fully amazing.
  • We are like two poltergeists - unique alone, but powerful together.
  • The Grim Reaper can take me now because my life was complete when I met you.
  • Are you a werewolf? Because my heart howls when it sees you.
  • Just like a haunted house, my heart horror-fyingly beats for you.
  • Are you a white walker? Because my heart freezes when I see you.
  • Call me a ghost because I want to be your boo.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What exactly is a 'scary' pick-up line?

A 'scary' pick-up line is a flirtatious sentence or phrase designed to initiate conversation with a potential romantic interest using elements of horror, spooky puns, or generally eerie themes. It's a light-hearted way to incorporate the thrill of the unconventional into a romantic setting.

2. Are 'scary' pick-up lines suitable for everyone?

'Scary' pick-up lines are certainly not for everyone. They are most effective for people who share an interest in genres of horror, the macabre, or simply enjoy an unconventional approach to conversation.

3. Should I use a 'scary' pick-up line on someone I've just met?

It depends on the context and the person. If you're at a Halloween event or discussing favorite horror movies, it could add a fun twist. However, using them without any context or with someone not open to such humor might not generate a positive response.

4. Can a 'scary' pick-up line actually work?

Like any other pick-up line, its success largely depends on delivery, the receiver's sense of humor, and the existing rapport. Ensuring it's all in good fun and not genuinely frightening is key to making it work.


In the roller coaster of romance, why must we always stick to the flat tracks? Let's climb steep heights and experience the thrill of the fall. These scary pick-up lines may seem unconventional, but they hold the potential to transform an ordinary encounter into an experience you’ll remember, laced with an eerie yet exciting element of surprise.

The key, however, is to understand the fine line that separates 'scary' from 'creepy.' The goal should never be to fear but to intrigue and to incite interest. Humor, confidence, and a touch of creativeness can work wonders with these eccentric conversation starters. It's all about the execution, timing, and most importantly, respecting the other person's comfort zone.

Indeed, love and fear are emotions resting on opposite ends of the spectrum. However, those daring to tread the uncanny path might find an unpredictable fusion of both—a strange, exhilarating taste of the unknown. After all, isn't life too short to always stick with the ordinary? So, next Halloween, or perhaps even a casual night out, if you wish to delve into an 'adventurous' romantic endeavour, these scary pick-up lines may be your perfect partners in crime. Hopefully, these spine-tingling lines will not only give you a good laugh but also provide an eerie yet enjoyable spark to your conversations.

Copyright © OnlyCaptions.Com 2023. All Rights Reserved.